The Refuge and the Protestant Bank (seventeenth to eighteenth centuries) — a part of the book Geneva as an International Financial Centre by Dr Alexander Ressos.
Between the end of the sixteenth century and the French Revolution, Geneva became a financial centre. The small Reformed republic, which had hardly any bankers in Calvin’s day, was home in the eighteenth century to an elite of capitalists whose funds fed the loans of the European monarchies, and it supplied Paris, Lyon, Amsterdam and London with some of the most prominent bankers of their time. Two Genevans would even direct the finances of the kingdom of France on the eve and at the outset of the Revolution. This rise was by no means a foregone conclusion. It resulted from the convergence of the institutions inherited from the Reformation, the influx of Huguenot refugees, the growth of export industries, the accumulation of capital in a prudent oligarchy and the considerable financial needs of the great states.
Part C retraces this convergence in five chapters. The first describes the successive waves of the Refuge and the formation of the Geneva Fabrique, that cluster of luxury industries — watchmaking, jewellery, gilding, printed calicoes — which enriched the city. The second presents the “Protestant Bank”, in the phrase of the historian Herbert Lüthy, that is to say the network of Huguenot and Genevan bankers which played a major role in French and European finance. The third follows four Genevans in the service of the finances of the king of France: Isaac Thellusson, Jacques Necker, Isaac Panchaud and Étienne Clavière. The fourth analyses a celebrated financial innovation, investments in life annuities on the lives of young Genevan girls, often referred to as the “thirty maidens of Geneva”. The fifth retraces the political crises of the Republic in the eighteenth century, the French annexation of 1798 and the Restoration of 1813-1815, which would make Geneva a Swiss canton.
The guiding thread of this part is the relationship between a small financial centre and a large neighbouring state. In the fifteenth century, the France of Louis XI had ruined the Geneva fairs. In the eighteenth century, the France of Louis XV and Louis XVI became the principal debtor of the Genevan capitalists. This dependence yielded considerable profits, and then severe losses when the monarchy collapsed. The lesson of risk concentration, already encountered in Part A, here takes on a spectacular dimension.
The historiography of this period is particularly rich. Herbert Lüthy’s monumental study of the Protestant bank in France, the work of Anne-Marie Piuz and Liliane Mottu-Weber on the Geneva economy, and research on French public debt and on life annuities provide a solid foundation.1 The figures and dates cited in the pages that follow nevertheless remain subject to verification, and the notes say so.
This part belongs to Geneva as an International Financial Centre by Dr Alexander Ressos, published here in full, section by section.
The waves of the Refuge and the Geneva Fabrique — overview and summary
For more than two centuries, Geneva was a place of refuge for persecuted Protestants. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankFrom the first to the second Refuge
Historians usually distinguish two great waves of Protestant refugees in Geneva. The first Refuge corresponds to the sixteenth century, and in particular to the 1550s and 1560s, when persecution in… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe revocation of the Edict of Nantes and the Huguenot exodus
In October 1685, Louis XIV revoked the Edict of Nantes by the Edict of Fontainebleau. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGeneva, a city of transit and refuge under surveillance
The mass arrival of refugees placed Geneva in a delicate position. The Republic wished to assist its co-religionists, in keeping with its tradition and its identity. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe cost and the return of refuge
Taking in refugees has a cost. They must be housed, fed and cared for, and sometimes helped to establish themselves. These expenses weigh on public finances and on the institutions of welfare. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Fabrique: watchmaking and jewellery
In the eighteenth century, the Genevans used the name “Fabrique” to designate the whole range of trades connected with watchmaking, jewellery, goldsmithing, engraving, enamelling and related… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankIndiennes and gilt thread: export industries
Alongside the Fabrique, other export industries developed in Geneva during the eighteenth century. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankA stratified society: citizens, burghers, natives, residents
The prosperity of the eighteenth century went hand in hand with a pronounced social and legal stratification. The population of Geneva was divided into several categories with different rights. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankFrom manufacturing to finance: Genevan accumulation
In the course of the eighteenth century, part of the fortunes born of trade and manufacturing turned towards finance. Several reasons explain this movement. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGenevan trade in the eighteenth century: routes, products and partners
Genevan trade in the eighteenth century rested on a twofold movement. The city exported valuable manufactured goods — watches, jewellery, enamels, indiennes, gilt thread — to France, Italy, Germany,… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankVoltaire, Rousseau and the image of Geneva
The eighteenth century was also the century in which Geneva became a centre of European intellectual life. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe integration of refugees into the elites
Families of refugee origin did not remain outside power. Over the generations, many acquired burgher status and then allied themselves with the old families through marriage. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Fabrique faces competition: the Jura, Neuchâtel and France
The prosperity of the Genevan Fabrique attracted imitators. In the course of the eighteenth century, watchmaking developed in the Neuchâtel mountains and in the Jura, notably at Le Locle and La… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe refugees and the birth of cross-border wealth advice
The Huguenot exodus created a new demand: for advisers capable of helping dispersed families to manage assets located in several countries. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankChecklist: assessing the economic effects of welcoming foreign talent
Take stock of the skills and capital brought by the new arrivals and set them against the needs of the local economy. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Protestant Bank: Huguenot networks from Geneva to London — overview and summary
In the eighteenth century, a significant part of French high finance was in the hands of Protestant bankers, whether French, Genevan or Swiss, even though Protestantism was prohibited in the kingdom. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankWhat Herbert Lüthy called the “Protestant Bank”
The expression “Banque protestante” (Protestant Bank) is associated with the Swiss historian Herbert Lüthy, who devoted to it a two-volume study published between the late 1950s and the early 1960s. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe ingredients of a network: family, faith, correspondence
The network of the Protestant Bank rested on several ingredients, whose combination explains its effectiveness. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGeneva within the network: a centre of capital and refuge
Geneva occupies a singular position within the network of Protestant banking. Paris and, to a lesser extent, Lyon, Amsterdam and London are the principal centres of operations. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe wars of Louis XIV and Huguenot credit
The first great test of Protestant banking comes during the last wars of Louis XIV. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe geography of the network: Paris, Lyon, Amsterdam, London
The network of Protestant banking extends across several centres, each of which fulfils a specific function. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe techniques of the trade
The Protestant bankers of the eighteenth century practise a set of trades that would be distinguished today, but which were then combined within the same houses. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankLaw’s System: a lesson in bubbles
In the aftermath of the death of Louis XIV, France is weighed down by debt. The Scotsman John Law proposes a bold reform to the Regent: to create a bank issuing paper money, and then a trading… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe limits of the model
Protestant banking enjoyed remarkable success, but its model had limits that events would reveal. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankLegacies: houses that endure
Several houses that grew out of Protestant banking have survived across the centuries. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe life of a banking house in the eighteenth century
A banking house of the eighteenth century is a small organisation. It brings together a few partners, often relatives, a small number of clerks and a few employees responsible for bookkeeping and… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Refuge and the birth of an international business law
The Huguenot exodus raised complex legal questions, which contributed to the development of a business law oriented towards international affairs. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGeneva and London: investments in the English funds
Alongside French debt, Geneva’s capitalists invest in British public funds. After the revolution of 1688, England put in place a system of public credit founded on the authority of Parliament, which… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe confidentiality of correspondence and the protection of information
Information constituted the principal asset of the bankers of the eighteenth century, and its protection a constant concern. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGeneva and Amsterdam: the exchange bank and the bills market
In the seventeenth century and for much of the eighteenth, Amsterdam held first place among the financial centres of Europe. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankChecklist: assessing a network of correspondent banks
Identify the financial centres covered by the network and the function each of them performs in the institution’s operations. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGenevans in charge of the king’s finances: Thellusson, Necker, Panchaud, Clavière — overview and summary
In the eighteenth century several Genevans held eminent positions in French finance. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe French monarchy and its creditors
To understand the role of the Genevan bankers, one must first recall the financial situation of the French monarchy in the eighteenth century. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankIsaac Thellusson, resident of Geneva and banker to the king
Isaac Thellusson, born into a refugee family settled in Geneva, made his career in banking in Paris during the first half of the eighteenth century. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankJacques Necker: from the counting house to the control of the finances
Jacques Necker was born in Geneva in 1732, into a family of German origin settled in the city. He left young for Paris, where he entered banking. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Compte rendu au roi: transparency as a weapon
In 1781 Necker published the Compte rendu au roi [Account rendered to the King], a document presenting the state of the kingdom’s finances. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankIsaac Panchaud and the Caisse d’escompte
Isaac Panchaud, a banker of Vaudois origin, born in London and established in Paris, is a less familiar figure than Necker, but his influence on the financial ideas of his time was considerable. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankÉtienne Clavière: from the Genevan revolution to the Ministry of Finance
Étienne Clavière was born in Geneva in 1735, into a family of merchants of French origin. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Genevans in the financial crisis of the monarchy
The presence of Genevans in key positions in French finance, and the weight of Genevan capital in the royal debt, made Geneva a party to the financial crisis that led to the Revolution. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankLessons for the management of sovereign risk
Geneva’s experience at the end of the eighteenth century offers several lessons for the management of sovereign risk, lessons with which contemporary wealth managers are well acquainted. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankCoppet: finance, ideas and politics
After his retirement, Necker settled at the château de Coppet, on the Vaud shore of Lake Geneva, which he had acquired a few years earlier. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe debates on public debt, from Necker to the present day
Necker’s financial policy provoked a debate that continues to this day on the proper way to finance the exceptional expenditure of the state. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankComparative portraits
The four Genevans presented in this chapter followed different trajectories, but taken together their careers illuminate the role of the financial centre in eighteenth-century European finance. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankA Genevan at the United States Treasury: Albert Gallatin
The line of Genevans in the service of a great state’s finances does not end with France. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe banker turned minister: conflicts of interest and legitimacy
Necker’s career raises a question that remains topical: that of conflicts of interest between private finance and public office. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankPublic finance and public opinion: a modern debate
Necker’s Compte rendu brought the finances of the state into public debate. In the years that followed, pamphlets, memoirs and articles devoted to the debt, to loans and to taxation multiplied. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankChecklist: analysing an exposure to sovereign risk
Measure the share of the assets exposed to each state, directly or indirectly, through bonds, bank deposits, guarantees and counterparties. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankLife annuities and the “thirty maidens of Geneva” — overview and summary
Among the financial innovations of the eighteenth century, few have captured the imagination as much as the Genevan investments in French life annuities constituted on the lives of carefully selected… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankWhat is a life annuity?
A life annuity is a contract by which a debtor undertakes to pay a periodic sum for the duration of the life of a specified person, in return for a capital sum received. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe life annuity loans of the French monarchy
In the eighteenth century, the French monarchy regularly issued life annuities to finance its deficits. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Genevan idea: choosing the lives
The Genevan capitalists grasped very early the advantage offered by the uniform pricing of French life annuities. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe scheme: a life annuity fund before its time
The practical operation of these schemes varied from banker to banker and from period to period, but their general structure can be described as follows. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankA contested innovation
Historians long presented the “thirty maidens of Geneva” as a picturesque anecdote. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankWhy did the monarchy accept this bargain?
It may seem surprising that a state as powerful as France sold life annuities for decades on terms so unfavourable to itself. Several factors explain this situation. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Genevan investors: the scale and fragility of their exposure
Investments in French life annuities came to occupy a considerable place in Genevan fortunes at the end of the eighteenth century. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe science of longevity: medicine, mathematics and finance
The Genevan schemes rested on an understanding of mortality that was still empirical. The eighteenth century was a period of decisive progress in this field. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankFrom the thirty maidens to contemporary products
Several contemporary financial instruments rest on the same logic as the Genevan schemes: the assessment and pooling of longevity risk. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankLessons for investors and issuers
The story of the thirty maidens offers several lessons, of interest to investors and to issuers of financial products alike. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe practical workings: certificates of life, powers of attorney and disputes
The success of the Genevan schemes rested on rigorous logistics. In order to collect the arrears, the holders had to prove at regular intervals that the lives were still living. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankA European comparison: England and the United Provinces
France was not the only state to sell life annuities. The United Provinces had long resorted to them, and the Grand Pensionary Johan de Witt had presented, as early as the seventeenth century, a… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankWhat the thirty maidens tell us about the Geneva financial centre
The episode of the thirty maidens sums up several characteristics of the Geneva financial centre. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankTontines: a cousin of the thirty maidens
The tontine, mentioned at the beginning of this chapter, is closely related to the Genevan schemes. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankChecklist: assessing a longevity-linked product
Verify that the pricing rests on current mortality tables suited to the population concerned, and identify the sensitive assumptions. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Republic in crisis: revolutions, annexation and Restoration (1707-1815) — overview and summary
The Genevan eighteenth century was a century of prosperity and of conflict. While the Fabrique exported its watches across Europe and the capitalists placed their funds in Paris and London, the… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankA contested oligarchy
At the beginning of the eighteenth century, real power belonged to a small number of families that dominated the Petit Conseil (Small Council) and the Conseil des Deux-Cents (Council of Two Hundred). Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankReprésentants and Négatifs
In the middle of the century, Genevan political life came to be organised around two parties. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant Bank1781–1782: revolution and foreign intervention
In the early 1780s the crisis reached its climax. In 1781 the Représentants, allied with the natifs, secured the adoption of an edict granting the latter new rights. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant Bank1789–1794: the Genevan revolution
The French Revolution once again upended the situation in Geneva. The regime imposed in 1782 could not withstand the spread of revolutionary ideas. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe finances of the revolutionary Republic
The Genevan revolution had to contend with considerable financial difficulties. State revenues fell as the economy slowed, while expenditure rose, in particular for the relief of the unemployed of… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant Bank1798: the annexation
At the end of the eighteenth century the Republic of Geneva was an enclave within French territory, France having annexed Savoy and the Pays de Gex. Its independence became untenable. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankFrench Geneva: blockade, conscription and decline
The French period was one of economic decline for Geneva, as the Archives d’État note. Several factors explain this decline. The wars of the Revolution and the Empire disrupted European trade. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankGenevan bankers in Napoleonic France
While Geneva’s economy declined, the bankers of Genevan and Swiss origin established in Paris regained an important position under the Consulate and the Empire. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant Bank1813–1815: the Restoration and entry into the Confederation
The fall of the Napoleonic Empire gave Geneva the opportunity to regain its independence. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankWhat the crisis taught the financial centre
The long Genevan crisis of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries left lessons that the financial centre of the nineteenth century would absorb. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe free zones: a tailor-made economic frontier
The free zones created around Geneva at the time of its entry into the Confederation are a remarkable legal innovation. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankFrom city-state to canton: losses and gains
Entry into the Confederation profoundly transformed Geneva’s situation. The city lost some of the attributes of a sovereign state. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Société économique and the management of collective assets
The Société économique, created in 1798 to administer the property of the former Republic, deserves particular attention. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe memory of the crises in Genevan identity
The trials of the Republic have left lasting traces in the collective memory. The Escalade of 1602 is commemorated every December with processions, songs and the famous chocolate cauldron. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankEconomic life under the French administration
The French period transformed the daily economic life of the Genevans. The city was integrated into the fiscal and customs system of the Empire. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankThe Genevan elites and the Empire
The Genevan elites adopted a variety of attitudes towards French rule. Some notables collaborated with the imperial administration, held public office and took part in the life of the departmental… Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankConclusion to Part C
Between the seventeenth century and the Restoration, Geneva became a centre of capital. Read more Geneva · The Refuge and the Protestant BankChecklist: assessing the political risk of a jurisdiction for the custody of assets
Examine the stability of the political institutions and the degree to which the population supports the system of government. Read more